Economy
Feature Chart 1Weak Economic Fundamentals Undermine Stock Performance Monetary policy easing has intensified in the past two months. The PBoC reduced one-year loan prime rate (LPR) by 10 bps and five-year by 5 bps following last week’s 10bps cut in policy rates1 and December’s 50 bps drop in the reserve requirement rate (RRR). Nonetheless, the onshore financial market’s response to the monetary policy actions has been muted. China’s A-share market price index fell by 3% in the past month. Credit growth has bottomed, but there is no sign of a strong rebound despite recent rate decreases (Chart 1, top panel). The impaired monetary policy transmission mechanism will likely delay China’s economic recovery, which normally lags the credit cycle by six to nine months. Moreover, the marginal propensity to spend among both corporates and households continues to decline, highlighting a lack of confidence among real economy participants, and will in turn dampen the positive effects of policy stimulus (Chart 2). The poor performance of Chinese onshore stocks (in absolute terms) is due to a muted improvement in credit growth and deteriorating economic fundamentals (Chart 1, bottom panel). Our model shows that China’s corporate profits are set to contract in next six months, implying that the risk-reward profile of Chinese stocks in absolute terms is not yet attractive (Chart 3). Therefore, investors should maintain an underweight allocation to Chinese equities for the time being. Chart 2Lack Of Confidence Dampens Corporate Earnings Outlook Chart 3China's Corporate Profits Set To Contract In Next Six Months Qingyun Xu, CFA Associate Editor qingyunx@bcaresearch.com Improving Liquidity, Weakening Credit Demand The modest uptick in December’s total social financing (TSF) growth largely reflects a significant increase in government bond issuance, while bank loan growth continued on a downward trend (Chart 4). Corporate loan demand remained sluggish, which dragged down aggregate bank credit growth (Chart 5). Downbeat business confidence suggests that corporate demand for credit will take longer to turn around, and therefore will reduce the effectiveness of current easing measures. Chart 4Monetary Easing Since Q3 Has Failed To Boost Credit Growth So Far Chart 5Corporate Demand For Loans Weaker Than Suggested By Headline Data Meanwhile, corporate bill financing has risen rapidly in recent months and now accounts for almost 40% of new bank loans, the highest level since 2010 (Chart 5, bottom panel). The high share of short-term lending to the corporate sector highlights the underlying weakness in both loan supply and demand. Banks are risk averse and reluctant to approve longer-term credit to the corporate sector, while corporates are unwilling to take on more debt. As a result, banks have had to issue short-term bills in order to meet their lending quota. Proactive Fiscal Policy Will Have A Limited Impact On Infrastructure Investments Chart 6Local Government SPBs Will Be Frontloaded In 2022 Fiscal policy will likely be frontloaded in Q1 this year, but the impact of a proactive fiscal policy on boosting infrastructural investment may be limited. According to a statement by the Ministry of Finance last December, around RMB1.46 trillion in the quota for local government special purpose bonds (SPBs) has been frontloaded for 2022. If we assume that all of the SPBs will be issued in Q1, the amount will be higher than SPBs issued during the same period in 2019, 2020 and 2021 (Chart 6). We expect a total SPBs quota of RMB 3.5 trillion for 2022, roughly the same as 2021. This implies a zero fiscal impulse on SPBs in 2022 compared with 2021. However, there were an estimated 1.2 trillion in SPB proceeds in 2021 that local governments failed to invest and this amount could be deployed in 2022. If we add last year’s SPB carryover to this year’s quota, there may be a 30% increase in the available funds to invest in infrastructure projects in 2022. Chart 7Higher LG Bond Issuance Does Not Mean Substantial Boost In Infrastructure Spending However, a 30% jump in SPB proceeds does not suggest an equal boost in infrastructure spending this year (Chart 7). As noted in previous reports, SPBs issued by local governments only account for around 15% of total funding for infrastructure spending. Bank loans, which remain in the doldrums, are a much more significant driver in supporting the sector’s investment. Secondly, infrastructure spending has structurally downshifted since 2017 due to a sweeping financial deleveraging campaign to rein in shadow banking activity by local government financing vehicles (LGFVs). Shadow banking activity, which is highly correlated with infrastructure investment growth, is stuck in a deep contraction with no signs of an imminent turnaround (Chart 7, bottom panel). Thirdly, land sales play a prominent role in local government financing, accounting for more than 40% of local government aggregate revenues2 compared with about 15% from SPBs (Chart 8). Local government fiscal spending power will be constrained due to a significant and ongoing slowdown in land sales and regulatory pressures on LGFVs (Chart 8, bottom panel). Therefore, we expect that infrastructure spending will only moderately rebound in 2022. At best, it will return to its pre-pandemic rate of around 4% (year-over-year) in 2022 (Chart 9, top panel). Notably, onshore infrastructure stocks have priced in the recent favorable news about proactive fiscal policy support in 2022 (Chart 9, bottom panel). Given that infrastructure investment will likely only improve modestly this year, on a cyclical basis the sector’s stock performance upside will be capped and renewed weakness is likely. Chart 8Government Funds Face Headwinds From Falling Land Sales Chart 9Infrastructure Investment Will Likely Recover To Its Pre-Pandemic Growth Rate More Policy Fine-Tuning Is Underway, But Housing Policy Reversal Remains Doubtful Last week’s 5bp reduction in the 5-year LPR, which serves as a benchmark for mortgage loans, was positive for the housing market. However, the cut is insufficient to revive the demand for housing. Moreover, the asymmetrical rate reductions - a 10bps drop in the 1-year LPR versus a 5bps reduction in the 5-year - signals that the authorities are reluctant to decisively reverse housing policies. Sentiment in the housing sector remains downbeat. A survey conducted by the PBoC shows that the willingness to buy a home has plunged to the lowest level since 2017 (Chart 10). Medium- to long-term household loan growth, which is highly correlated with home sales, decelerated further in December (Chart 10, bottom panel). Given that home prices continue to decline, buyers may be expecting more price discounts and refrain from making purchases despite slightly cheaper mortgage rates. Although there was a modest pickup in medium- to long-term consumer loan growth in November, it was mainly driven by pent-up mortgage applications delayed by the banks in Q3. Moreover, advance payments for real estate developers remained in contraction through end-2021. The prolonged weakness in the demand for mortgages and homes highlights our view that it will take more than a minor mortgage rate cut to revive sentiment (Chart 11). Chart 10Sentiment In Housing Market Has Plummeted To A Multi-Year Low Chart 11Funding Among Real Estate Developers Has Not Improved Without a decisive improvement in home sales, real estate developers will continue to face funding constraints, which will weigh on new investment and housing projects (Chart 12). We expect the contraction in real estate investment and housing starts to be sustained through at least 1H22 (Chart 13). Chart 12Policymakers Will Have To Allow Significant Re-leveraging To Revive Housing Demand Chart 13Real Estate Investment And Housing Starts Will Remain In Contraction Through 1H22 Chinese Export Growth Will Converge To Long-Term Growth Chart 14Vigorous Exports Provided Crucial Support To China's Economy In 2021 China’s exports grew vigorously in 2021, providing critical support to the economy. Net exports contributed 1.7 percentage points to the 8.1% rate of real GDP growth in 2021, the highest growth contribution since 2006. China’s share of global exports expanded to more than 15%, about 2 percentage points higher than the pre-pandemic average from 2015 to 2019 (Chart 14). The export sector probably will not repeat last year’s strong performance. The widening divergence of exports in value and in volume suggests that the solid aggregate value of exports has been mainly buttressed by soaring export prices since July 2021 (Chart 15). The price effect will likely gradually abate in 2022 due to easing global supply chain constraints, softer global economic growth and a high base factor from 2021. Indeed, export prices from China and other industrialized countries may have already peaked (Chart 16). Chart 15Robust Exports Growth Since 2H21 Driven By Soaring Export Prices Chart 16Export Prices May Have Peaked Services spending worldwide will likely normalize and lead global demand growth in 2022. Meanwhile, goods spending will moderate, implying weaker demand for China’s manufactured goods (Chart 17). Furthermore, China’s strong exports to emerging markets (EM) since Q2 2021 reflected supply shortages due to production interruptions in the EMs (Chart 18). We expect supply chain disruptions in these economies to ease in 2H22 when Omicron-induced infections subside and antiviral treatments become available worldwide. As such, China’s exports to those regions may gradually return to pre-pandemic levels. Chart 17US Household Consumption Will Likely Rotate From Goods To Services In 2022 Chart 18Rising Exports To EMs In 2021 May Not Continue Into 2022 China’s manufacturing utilization capacity reached a historical high in 2021, supported by hardy external demand for goods. However, profit margins in the manufacturing sector have been squeezed due to surging input costs (Chart 19). Manufacturing investment growth has been falling, reflecting the reluctance by manufacturers to expand their business operations amid narrowing profit margins (Chart 20). The profit outlook for the manufacturing sector will be at risk of deterioration when the growth in both export volumes and prices moderate in 2022. Chart 19Manufacturing Sector's Profit Margins Have Been Squeezed Chart 20Manufacturing Investment Growth And Output Volume Both Rolled Over Rising Import Prices Mask The Weakness In Chinese Domestic Demand Chinese import growth in value remained resilient through December, but has increasingly been driven by rising import prices. Import growth in volume, which is a truer picture of China’s domestic demand, decelerated at a faster rate in 2H21 (Chart 21). Credit impulse, which normally leads import growth by around six months, only ticked up slightly. The minor improvement in the rate of Chinese credit expansion will provide limited support to the country’s imports in 1H 2022 (Chart 22). Chart 21Rising Import Prices Masked The Weakness In China's Domestic Demand Chart 22Modest Rebound In Credit Impulse Will Provide Limited Support To Chinese Imports Chart 23Chinese Imports Of Key Commodities Rebounded Aimed Easing In Production Constraints The volume of Chinese-imported key commodities, such as iron ore and steel, rebounded in the past three months, but its growth remains in contraction on a year-on-year basis (Chart 23). The improvement in Chinese commodity imports, in our view, reflects an easing in production constraints rather than escalating demand. Recently released economic data, ranging from manufacturing PMI, industrial production, fixed-asset investment and construction activity, all point to an imbalanced supply-demand picture in China’s economy (discussed in the next section). Sluggish Quarterly Economic Growth At End Of 2021 China’s economy expanded by 8.1% in 2021 or at a 5.1% average annual rate in the past two years. However, quarterly GDP growth on a year-over-year basis slowed further to 4% in Q4 from 4.9% in the previous quarter. On a sequential basis, seasonally adjusted GDP growth in Q4 was 1.6 percentage points above that of Q3, but slightly below its historical mean (Chart 24). Chart 24Subdued GDP Growth In Q4 Chart 25Investment And Consumption Have Been Poor Economic Links Chart 26Softness In Investment And Consumption More Than Offset Robust Exports Although industrial production accelerated somewhat in December, it reflects a catch-up phase following a period of constrained output amid last fall’s energy crisis (Chart 25). On the other hand, lackluster domestic demand and a further slowdown in the housing market significantly dragged down China’s economic expansion in Q4. Both fixed-asset investment and consumption decelerated significantly in 2021 Q4, more than offsetting an improvement in net exports (Chart 26, top panel). Notably, year-over-year growth rates in construction and real estate components of real GDP fell below zero in Q4 (Chart 26, bottom panel). In light of the subdued credit growth through end-2021, China’s economic activity will not regain its footing until mid-2022. Slow Recovery In Household Consumption Likely Through 1H22 The household consumption recovery was sluggish in 2021 and it will face strong headwinds at least through 1H22. China’s consumption recovery has been hindered by a worsening labor market situation, depressed household sentiment and renewed threats from flareups in domestic COVID-19 cases. China’s labor market situation shows a mixed picture. The urban unemployment rate has dropped to pre-pandemic levels and stabilized at 5.1% in December. It remains well within the government’s 2021 unemployment target of “around 5.5%”. However, urban new job creations plunged sharply and the number of migrant workers returning to the cities remains far below the pre-pandemic trend (Chart 27). China’s imbalanced economic recovery in the past two years led to a substantially slower pace of job creation in labor-intensive service sectors (Chart 28). Moreover, wages have been cut and the unemployment rate among younger workers have climbed rapidly in sectors suffering from last year’s regulatory crackdowns in real estate, education and internet platforms. Even though policies have recently eased at margin, it will take time for labor market dynamics (a lagging indicator) to improve. Chart 27Labor Market Situation Is Worsening Chart 28Imbalanced Economic Recovery Led To A Mixed Picture In The Labor Market Chinese household expenditures have lagged disposable incomes since the outbreak of the pandemic (Chart 29). The propensity to consume has declined since 2018 and the downward trend has been exacerbated by the pandemic since early 2020 along with a soaring preference to save (Chart 30). Chart 29Chinese Household Expenditures Have Lagged Disposable Income Growth Chart 30Poor Sentiment On Future Income Contributes To Consumers' Unwillingness To Spend Household consumption also faces renewed threats from increases in domestic COVID-19 cases. Since Q3 last year, more frequent city-wide lockdowns and inter-regional travel bans have had profound negative effects on the country’s service sector and retail sales (Chart 31 & 32). Omicron has also spread to China, triggering new waves of stringent countermeasures. China will not abandon its zero-tolerance policy towards COVID anytime soon, thus we expect the stop-and-go economic reopening to continue to weigh on the country’s service sector activity and consumption at least through 1H22. Chart 32Service Sector Activities Struggle To Return To Pre-Pandemic Trends Chart 31China's Stringent COVID Countermeasures Will Curb Service Sector Recovery In 2022 Table 1China Macro Data Summary Table 2China Financial Market Performance Summary Footnotes 1 The 7-day reverse repo and the 1-year Medium-term Lending Facility (MLF) rates. 2 Including local government budgetary and managed funds revenues. Strategic View Cyclical Recommendations Tactical Recommendations
Highlights Federal Reserve: Market turbulence will not dissuade the Fed from starting to hike rates in March, with longer-term consumer inflation expectations climbing steadily higher. Given the choice of fighting high inflation or supporting asset prices, the Fed will choose the former as tightening financial conditions are not yet an impediment to above-trend US economic growth. Canada: Canadian growth is set to recover as the intense Omicron wave has peaked, further intensifying inflationary pressures. The Bank of Canada has all the information from its consumer and business surveys to justify hiking rates immediately, particularly with inflation expectations above the central bank’s 1-3% target range. Stay underweight Canadian government bonds in global fixed income portfolios, as markets have not yet discounted the likely cyclical peak in policy interest rates. Feature Chart of the WeekA Less Friendly Policy Backdrop For Risk Assets Risk assets have taken a beating over the past week, with major equity indices in the US and Europe suffering the sharpest selloffs seen since the early days of the pandemic. There are many sources of investor angst fueling the risk aversion wave - a potential Russian invasion of Ukraine, some mixed results on Q4/2021 corporate earnings reports, the lingering Omicron wave and most importantly, fears of tighter global monetary policy. The latter is most evident in the US, with a few prominent Wall Street investment banks now calling for the Fed to deliver much more than the 3-4 rate hikes currently discounted for 2022. The Fed is now in a difficult spot. Realized US inflation remains very high, supply chain disruptions are not going away, and wage growth is accelerating amid tight US labor market conditions. Survey-based consumer inflation expectations show little sign of peaking, with longer-term expectations now climbing steadily higher. As a result, the Fed has been forced to rapidly shift its policy guidance in a more hawkish direction. These trends are not unique to the US, however, as similar inflation dynamics are playing out in places like the UK and Canada where central banks are also expected to deliver a lot of monetary tightening this year (Chart of the Week). For inflation targeting central banks, a surge in inflation that becomes increasingly embedded in longer-term inflation expectations is a direct challenge to their credibility. The policy prescription must involve monetary tightening to raise real interest rates in a bid to stabilize inflation expectations. At the same time, given the starting point of near-0% nominal policy rates and high inflation, deeply negative real interest rates have a lot of room to rise before becoming a serious restraint on economic growth. This limits how far bond yields can decline in response to a generalized risk-off move like the one seen over the past week. For financial markets hooked on easy monetary policies, an inflation-induced monetary tightening cycle will lead to even higher bond yields – especially real yields - and more frequent bouts of market volatility this year. The events of the past week will likely not be a one-off. The Fed Cares About Inflation, Not Your Equity Portfolio US equity markets have had a rough start to 2022. The S&P 500 is down -9% so far in January, with the tech-heavy NASDAQ index down a whopping -13% (Chart 2). The VIX index now sits at 31, nearly double the level seen at the end of 2021. The selloff in risk assets has occurred alongside an increase in real US bond yields. TIPS yields for the 2yr, 5yr and 10yr maturities are up +20bps, +36bps and +43bps, respectively since the start of the year - a reflection of increasing Fed rate hike expectations. Yet other financial markets have seen more limited swings so far in 2022. Non-US equities are sharply outperforming the US; the EuroStoxx index of European equities is down -6%, while the MSCI emerging market (EM) equity index is down just -2%. US investment grade and high-yield spreads, using the Bloomberg benchmark indices, are up a relatively modest +9bps and +36bps, respectively, while the DXY US dollar index is up only +0.4%. The risk asset selloff seen year-to-date has been sharp, but has likely not been enough for the Fed to postpone the expected March liftoff of the fed funds rate. US financial conditions have tightened, but not nearly by enough to make the Fed to more concerned about the US economic growth outlook (Chart 3). Also, financial markets appear to be functioning normally, suggesting what is happening is a repricing of risk assets rather than a selloff driven by poor market liquidity conditions. Chart 2A 'Real' Equity Market Correction Chart 3High Inflation, Not High Asset Values, is The Fed's Biggest Concern The bigger risk to US growth may actually come from high inflation, rather than falling asset values. Real US household income growth, derived from responses in the New York Fed’s Survey of Consumer Expectations to individual questions on incomes and inflation, is expected to contract -3% over the next year (bottom panel). Given that decline in perceived spending power, with inflation far exceeding wage growth, it is no surprise that the University of Michigan consumer confidence index is near an 8-year low. US business confidence has also been hit by high inflation. The NFIB survey of small business sentiment and the Conference Board survey of corporate CEO confidence declined in the latter half of 2021, largely in response to inflationary supply chain disruptions and labor shortages. Nearly one-quarter of NFIB survey respondents cite “inflation” as the single most important problem in operating their businesses. Economic sentiment has clearly taken a hit because of elevated US inflation, even with the US unemployment rate at 3.9% and overall real GDP growth remaining solidly above trend. This suggests that slowing inflation could actually provide a more sustainable boost to the US growth through improved confidence – if the Fed can first successfully engineer a “soft landing” for the economy once it begins hiking rates. The problem the Fed now faces is that the high inflation of the past year is starting to leak into longer-term survey-based measures of inflation expectations. 5-10 year ahead consumer inflation expectations from the University of Michigan survey are now at a 10-year high of 3.1%, while the 10-year-ahead inflation forecast from the Philadelphia Fed’s Survey of Professional Forecasters is at a 23-year high of 2.6% (Chart 4). Market-based inflation expectations like TIPS breakevens have stopped rising, as a more hawkish Fed has boosted real TIPS yields, but remain elevated at levels consistent with the Fed achieving, but not exceeding, it's 2% medium-term inflation target (bottom panel). The combination of a tight US labor market and consumers expecting more inflation raises the risk that the US could enter a wage-price spiral, where workers demand wage increases in response to higher inflation and companies are therefore forced to raise prices to maintain profitability. The conditions for a wage-price spiral seem to now be in place in the US (Chart 5): unemployment is low, wages are accelerating and a growing number of US workers are quitting jobs to find better work. Perhaps most importantly, US consumers are more uncertain about where inflation will be in the future. Chart 4US Inflation Expectations Becoming More Entrenched Chart 5The Start Of A US Wage/Price Spiral? The New York Fed Survey of Consumer Expectations asks respondents to place probabilities on certain ranges for future US inflation rates one and three years ahead. The probability-weighted average of those inflation rates is dubbed “inflation uncertainty”, and those have doubled over the past year from 2% to 4% (bottom panel). This means that the survey respondents now see higher inflation outcomes as more probable, which will likely result in increased wage demands to “keep up” with the cost of living. With the US labor market looking tight as a drum, amid extensive shortages of quality workers as reported in business confidence surveys, the odds of wage increases because of higher inflation instead of higher productivity – a.k.a. a wage-price spiral – have shot up significantly. Already, the 5-year-annualized growth rate of US unit labor costs has doubled since the start of the pandemic (Chart 6), evidence that wage increases are not being matched by faster productivity. Given the strong historical correlation between unit labor cost growth and core inflation in the US, the rise in the latter will be more persistent if US workers ask for bigger cost-of-living driven wage increases. Chart 6Rising US Labor Costs Provide A Lasting Boost To US Inflation Former Fed Chair Alan Greenspan famously described “price stability” – the Fed’s stated medium-term goal - as a situation where “… households and businesses need not factor expectations of changes in the average level of prices into their decisions.” This is clearly not the situation in the US today, which is why the Fed has no choice but to move ahead with interest rate increases to begin the road back to price stability. Financial market selloffs may actually assist the Fed in achieving that goal through tighter financial conditions, thereby limiting how much interest rates must increase to cool off above-trend US economic growth. Interest rates must still go up first, though – especially in real terms. Already, investors have adjusted to that reality by lifting their medium-term “real rate expectations”. We proxy the latter by taking the difference between the forward path for nominal US interest rates discounted in the US overnight index swap (OIS) curve and the forward path of US inflation discounted in the US CPI swap curve. Over just the past month, that market-implied forward path for the real fed funds rate has shifted from discounting an average level of around -1% over the next decade to something closer to -0.25% (Chart 7). We anticipate that those real rate expectations will move even higher as the Fed begins to hike rates in March and continues its tightening cycle over the next 1-2 years. This will underpin the move higher in US bond yields that we expect this year, for both government and corporate debt, with the benchmark 10-year Treasury yield reaching a high of 2.25% by year-end. Bottom Line: Market turbulence will not dissuade the Fed from starting to hike rates in March. Longer-term consumer inflation expectations are climbing steadily higher, which is starting to feed into higher wage demands in a very tight labor market. Given the choice of fighting high inflation or supporting asset prices, the Fed will choose the former as tightening financial conditions are not yet an impediment to above-trend US economic growth. Stay below-benchmark on US interest rate exposure, both in terms of duration and country allocation, in global bond portfolios. Canada Update: The BoC Has A Lot Of Work To Do The Bank of Canada (BoC) meets this week and we anticipate that the first rate hike of this tightening cycle will be announced. This will just be the beginning of what will likely be an extended cycle. Canadian monetary conditions are far too accommodative given above-trend growth and accelerating inflation. The BoC places a lot of analytical weight on its Business Outlook Survey when assessing the state of the Canadian economy. The Q4/2021 survey signaled very strong business confidence and robust demand (both domestic and foreign), with a growing majority of firms surveyed planning to increase investment and hiring over the next year (Chart 8). Survey respondents also reported significant capacity constraints, especially in industries that have experienced strong demand during the pandemic, like retail, manufacturing and housing. This is related to global supply chain disruptions, but also to intensifying labor shortages. Chart 8A Bright Outlook For The Canadian Economy The survey was conducted before the Omicron variant began to spread through Canada, which lead to the reimposition of severe economic restrictions. The number of Canadian COVID cases has peaked, however, and some restrictions have already begun to be lifted in Ontario, Canada’s largest province by population. The economic impact of Omicron will therefore be concentrated in the first couple of months of 2022 and should not derail the hiring and investment plans indicated in the Business Outlook Survey. A reacceleration of Canadian economic growth post-Omicron would magnify high Canadian inflation at a time of intense capacity constraints and tight labor markets. The Canadian unemployment rate fell to 5.9% in December, just 0.2 percentage points above the pre-COVID low seen in February 2020. Headline CPI inflation reached a 31-year high of 4.8% in December 2021, with trimmed CPI inflation (which omits the most volatile components) reaching an 30-year high of 3.7% (Chart 9). The rise in inflation has been broad-based, with large increases seen for both goods inflation (6.8%) and services inflation (3.7%). Like the US, high inflation is becoming more embedded in survey-based inflation expectations. Canadian businesses expect inflation to be 3.2% over the next two years, according to the Business Outlook Survey.1 Canadian consumers expect inflation to be 4.9% over the next year and 3.5% over the next five years, according to the BoC’s Canadian Survey Of Consumer Expectations (Chart 10). The latter had been very stable around 3% since the survey began back in 2014, thus the 0.5 percentage point jump seen in the latest quarterly survey is a highly significant move that suggests the 2021 inflation surge is become more embedded in Canadian consumer psychology. Chart 9The BoC Has An Inflation Problem On Its Hands Chart 10Canadian Consumer Inflation Expectations Are Rising The Canadian inflation backdrop has similarities to the US situation described earlier in this report. Like the US, one-year-ahead Canadian consumer inflation expectations are far above wage expectations (only +2%), which suggests that Canadian consumers expect real wages to contract -2.9%. Also like the US, falling real wage expectations are acting as a drag on Canadian consumer confidence (bottom panel). And also like the US, we expect Canadian workers to increase their wage demands to restore real purchasing power, potentially starting a wage-price spiral. Given widespread Canadian labor market shortages, this process has likely already started. According to the BoC Business Outlook Survey, 43% of firms had to boost wages in Q4/2021 because of “cost of living adjustments”, compared to 29% in Q3/2021 (Chart 11). An even larger share of respondents in the Q4 survey (54%) reported having to raise wages to attract and retain workers, up significantly from Q3 and an indication of how Canadian firms are seeing their wage bill go up trying to find quality labor in a tight job market. Given the messages on growth and inflation from its surveys, the BoC has all the evidence it needs to begin the rate hiking process as soon as possible. The bigger question is how high will rates have to go to cool off Canadian economic growth and bring inflation back into the BoC’s 1-3% target range. The BoC’s own internal models estimate that the neutral level of the policy interest rate is between 1.75% and 2.75%. Those estimates were last produced back in April 2021, however, and the range may need to be revised higher to reflect the changes seen in the Canadian economy since then – most notably the greater supply constraints and higher inflation. At a minimum, the BoC will likely have to raise the policy rate to the higher end of its last estimated range for the neutral rate. Current market pricing in the Canadian OIS curve discounts the BoC hiking the policy rate from 0.25% today to 1.6% by the end of 2022 (Chart 12). With eight scheduled BoC policy meetings this year, including this week, the 2022 pricing is realistically achievable. However, only another 50bps of hikes are priced for 2023 and no additional hikes after that. Chart 12Markets Are Underestimating The Likely Cyclical Peak In Canadian Rates Chart 13Stay Underweight Canadian Government Bonds A peak policy rate around 2% would only be in the lower half of the BoC’s range of neutral rate estimates. It would also represent a very low peak real rate of 0% assuming inflation returns to the midpoint of the BoC target range. It is possible that markets are underestimating how high the BoC will have to lift rates, both in nominal and real terms, because of a fear that rate increases will hurt highly indebted Canadian homeowners and trigger a sharp pullback in house prices. This is a legitimate concern given the stretched housing valuations across most major Canadian cities. However, the BoC is facing the same credibility issue that the Fed and other inflation-targeting central banks are facing in the pandemic era. Canadian inflation is too high and becoming more embedded in inflation expectations. Also like the Fed, the BoC will have to fight the inflation battle now and deal with the collateral damage on financial conditions (and the housing market) later. Importantly, with the Fed also likely to deliver several rate hike in 2022. Thus, the BoC has less need to fear a surge in the Canadian dollar, driven by widening interest rate differentials, that could aggressively tighten financial conditions beyond the impact on asset markets and house prices from higher interest rates (Chart 13). Summing it all up, we maintain our negative strategic outlook on Canadian government bonds as markets are underestimating the tightening that will be required from the BoC over the next 1-2 years. Bottom Line: The Bank of Canada has all the information from its consumer and business surveys to justify hiking rates immediately, particularly with medium-term consumer inflation expectations now above the central bank’s 1-3% target range. Stay underweight Canadian government bonds in global fixed income portfolios, as markets have not yet discounted the likely cyclical peak in policy interest rates. Robert Robis, CFA Chief Fixed Income Strategist rrobis@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Business inflation expectations calculated as the share of respondents reporting expected inflation within a certain range multiplied by the midpoint of the range. We assume a value of 0.5 for “less than 1” and a value of 3.5 for “greater than 3”. GFIS Model Bond Portfolio Recommended Positioning Active Duration Contribution: GFIS Recommended Portfolio Vs. Custom Performance Benchmark The GFIS Recommended Portfolio Vs. The Custom Benchmark Index Global Fixed Income - Strategic Recommendations* Duration Regional Allocation Spread Product Tactical Overlay Trades
US consumer confidence deteriorated in January. The Conference Board’s headline index fell from 115.2 to 113.8 – which is better than the 111.2 expected. Worsening expectations explain this decline. The forward-looking index, which gauges the near-term…
The latest Business Conditions Survey from the National Association for Business Economics, which was conducted in the first two weeks of January, indicates that firms expect a profit margin compression. On the one hand, the survey reveals that business…
The German IFO Business Climate index increased by 0.9 points to 95.7 in January, surprising expectations of a deterioration. The improvement comes on the back of a stronger expectations component, which gained 2.5 points to 95.2 – above the anticipated 93.0.…
BCA Research’s US Equity Strategy service argues that the stars have not yet aligned for beaten-up US Tech stocks. A useful indicator of market breadth is the percentage of stocks making new lows – which currently stands at nearly 75%. Once this metric rises…
Flash PMIs for January indicate that the latest wave of COVID-19 infections is denting economic activity. The US Composite index declined sharply from 57.0 to 50.8 – barely above the 50 boom-bust line separating an expansion from a contraction. Similarly, the…
The sharp climb in US Treasury yields so far this year has sent a ripple through equity markets (see Market Focus). Interestingly, real yields are behind this move. The 10-year TIPS yield is 45 basis points higher since the beginning of the year. Meanwhile,…
Our Global Investment strategists often highlight that their “golden rule” for investing is to stay bullish on equities as long as a recession isn’t around the corner. This framework is instructive to assess the current environment. The question facing…
Highlights 2022 has had a rough start for equity investors: the S&P 500 is now down 8% from its peak, and NASDAQ is officially in correction territory. The question on everyone’s mind is how long this correction will last, and whether it is the right time to start buying beaten-up Tech stocks. Looking “under the hood” of the NASDAQ, we observe that with the technology space being top-heavy and dominated by the likes of Microsoft and Apple, index returns mask the heavy losses of some of the smaller, and less profitable, constituents, with many down 40-50% from their peaks. Analysis of the market breadth shows that three-quarters of NASDAQ names are trading below their one-week highs, which, according to our analysis, indicates that Tech is (almost) ripe for a bounce back. However, the sector is currently under duress from rising rates and imminent monetary tightening. Historically, Tech’s worst performance was two to three months prior to the first rate hike – the current pullback is a “textbook” behavior. It will take another couple of months after the rate hike for a sustainable rebound. In addition to headwinds from rising rates, there is also an ongoing slowdown in demand for tech products and services, which translates into a deceleration of earnings and sales growth. On the valuations front, Technology is trading with a significant premium to the market, while its expected earnings growth is on par with that of the S&P 500. We recommend investors to be patient: While Tech appears oversold, and recent volatility is a function of market panic, the stars have not yet aligned for the sector. We are tactically bearish but structurally bullish. Feature 2022 has had a rough start for equity investors: Since the beginning of January, the S&P 500 has pulled back 8%. Market consensus is that this violent rotation is a repricing of risk, triggered by the Fed’s new hawkish stance aimed at taming the runaway inflation that has surged to a nearly 40-year high. The market expects the first rate hike as soon as March, followed by three more into the year-end. It is also grappling with the timing and degree of quantitative tightening (QT), which will follow on the heels of tapering. Energy and Financials are the only sectors in the green so far this year, with Real Estate, Healthcare, and Tech being hit the hardest (Chart 1). Internet Retail is down almost 20% from its local peak in mid-2021 and Interactive Media, home of Facebook, is down 11%. NASDAQ is officially in correction territory (Chart 2). Rising rates have hit growth and interest-rate-sensitive areas of the market the hardest. While these negative returns indicate a sharp pullback, they don’t do justice to how painful this correction has been, as much of it was happening under the radar. The S&P 500 and many of its tech-related sectors and industries are top-heavy, being home to FAANG+M, which has proven to be more immune to rising rates. It is the smaller growth companies that have fallen much more than the top-line number indicates, with many down 40-50% from their peaks. However, now with more than 58% of stocks in the NASDAQ trading below their 30-week moving average, the natural question is: “Are we there yet?” or how much longer will this sell-off last? There are early signs of bottom-fishing among the stocks and industries hit hardest. Yet most days, both the S&P 500 and the NASDAQ start in the green, only to finish splattering to a new low (Chart 3). Chart 3Mega-cap Tech Has Fallen But Less Than Small-cap Brethren In this report, we will aim to gauge when the sell-off in tech names will have run its course by focusing on the S&P 500 Technology sector. Also in today’s publication, we will reverse our usual course of analysis: We will start from the technicals as they are most helpful for timing entry points, and we will follow with macro and fundamentals. Tech Sector Is Top Heavy The S&P 500 Technology sector is top-heavy, with each industry group dominated by one of the tech giants, such as Microsoft in Software and Services, Apple in Hardware and Equipment, and Nvidia in Semiconductors. We call this trio “MAN.” The MAN accounts for 50% of the S&P 500 Technology sector market capitalization (Chart 4). As a result, both sector performance and valuation are heavily affected by index composition. To unpack what is going on within the Tech sector, we plotted the dispersion of last month’s performance within the sector through a market cap bucket, with the first bucket containing the MANs. The last couple of buckets, 10 and 11, contain some of the smallest stocks in the index. Unsurprisingly, the largest stocks in the sector have not fallen that much. The correction has most affected stocks in buckets 7 through 11, with a market cap of between $8 to $33 billion, and these are the names that may be most tempting for “bottom-fishing.” Technicals It Is A Blood Bath Out There A useful indicator of market breadth, allowing us a look under the hood”, is the percentage of stocks making new lows – which currently stands at nearly 75% (Chart 5). This is a high reading which has happened only 11% of the months since 2000. However, once this metric rises above 85%, it indicates that the market is oversold. When that happens, the Tech sector outperforms the S&P 500 by around 7% over the next six months, and returns are positive every month (Chart 6). Based on this indicator, the NASDAQ in general, and Tech in particular, are close to the oversold conditions and are ready for a bounce. Chart 5Pullback In Tech Stocks Is Broad-based However, the BCA Technical Indicator for the sector (Chart 7) is still in neutral territory. It is driven primarily by momentum components: It gauges the trend in equities and determines if the market is at an extreme in terms of momentum or investor psychology. This indicator is highly affected by the performance of the largest index constituents. All in all, we conclude that from a technical standpoint, the Tech sector is getting closer to a rebound. Chart 7The Technical Indicator Is In The Neutral Territory Macroeconomic Backdrop New Rate Hiking Cycle Will Take Time Getting Used To Ok, Tech is oversold. Yet there is still the not-so-small matter of a new, tighter monetary regime. How does Tech fare in the environment of rising rates? Clearly, not so good so far. However, the question is, how long will it take for the higher rates to be priced in, and for Tech to rebound. To answer this question, we have run another empirical study, anchoring the performance of the Tech sector to the beginning of each hiking cycle since 1996 (Charts 8 and 9). According to our analysis, Tech’s worst performance is two to three months prior to the first rate hike – the current pullback in Tech is a perfect illustration. While we may expect a rebound rally “when the second shoe drops” and the Fed announces the first hike, it appears that a sustainable rally may still be a couple of months away. Based on this analysis, we conclude that it will pay off to be patient and wait until the summer. It Is The Economy, Stupid! Apart from the headwind from rising rates, there is also an ongoing slowdown in demand for Tech Business Investment (Chart 10). Moreover, the Tech New Orders Index peaked at a high level at the end of 2021 and has recently turned (Chart 11). So has Private Tech Investment (Chart 12). This indicates that demand is waning following the surge that accompanied the most recent push to digital transformation—which was accelerated by the onset of the pandemic. Chart 10Slowdown In Tech Business Investment Chart 11Tech New Orders Have Peaked Chart 12Private Tech Investment Is Also Slowing The macroeconomic backdrop is unfavorable for the Tech Sector Fundamentals Sales And Earnings Growth Are Slowing While the Tech sector enjoyed a fantastic sales recovery in 2021, with sales growth exceeding pre-pandemic levels, this year may be different. Waning demand for tech products and services translates into a sales growth slowdown (Chart 13). Chart 13The Tech Sector Sales Growth Is Slowing... Chart 14... So Is Earnings Growth With sales growth slowing, earnings growth is bound to follow (Chart 14), which is no different from the broad market. Technology sector earnings growth for the next 12 months is converging with that of the S&P 500: 10% vs. 9% respectively (Chart 15). Margins are expected to compress in 2022, albeit from the high levels (Chart 16). Chart 15Tech And The S&P 500 Expected Earnings Growth Has Converged Chart 16Margins Are Expected To Compress Of course, the Q4-2021 earnings results could bring a respite. So far blended the year-on-year earnings growth rate is 15.8%: However, only 5 companies out of 71 have reported, beating expectations by 4.6%. Will these results save the day? Possibly – expectations are a low bar to clear. Time will tell. But to prop up the sector, results from the MAN have got to be stellar. Valuations: Better But Not Good Enough While Tech earnings are expected to grow in line with the S&P 500, the sector is trading with a 28% premium to the market at 27x vs. 21x forward PE (Table 1). Relative PE NTM currently stands at 1.7 standard deviations above the five-year average. Although this may seem high, the froth has come off as, only two months ago, Tech was trading at 2.4 standard deviations. This is a significant change, but the sector is not yet cheap enough for bargain hunting. Adjusting for the growth rate differential between Tech and the S&P 500, we divide PE NTM over EPS Growth NTM, to arrive at PEG: Even so, Tech is still more expensive trading at 2.7 for a percentage of future growth, compared to 2.3 for the S&P 500. However, Tech is a growth sector, and perhaps by looking at only one-year-ahead earnings growth, we are being myopic. Let’s take a look at longer-term growth expectations. Curiously, over the next five years, Tech earnings are expected to grow at about an 18% annualized rate, while the S&P 500 is expected to grow at 21% (Chart 17). As a result, the PE/Long-Term Earnings Growth Rate for Tech is 1.5 vs. 1.0 for the S&P 500. Table 1Tech Valuation Premium Is Still Too High Chart 17Long-term Earnings Growth Does Not Justify Valuation Premium Either Of course, we need to keep in mind that since this sector is so top-heavy, the forward PE of the MAN affects overall sector valuations. As you can see in the table below (Table 2), MAN is trading with a premium to the sector. However, within the sector, companies with sky-high valuations are easier to find among smaller constituents (Chart 18). Valuations are elevated, while fundamentals are deteriorating Table 2The Largest Tech Companies Are Trading With A Premium To The Sector Investment Implications While it is tempting to add to Technology on the back of this pullback, we recommend caution. Tech is oversold and recent volatility is a function of market panic, yet the stars have not yet aligned for the sector. Historically, Tech has delivered negative returns several months prior to rate hikes and underperformed the broad market. Economic normalization also brings a slowdown in demand for tech goods and services, which translates into less exciting sales and earnings growth, and margin compression. Although some froth has come off, valuations for the sector remain elevated, and the premium over the S&P 500 is not justified. The scorecard summarizes each of these points, and it is clear that, on balance, the sector has quite a few challenges ahead (Table 3). Table 3Technology Sector Scorecard On a more optimistic note, this sell-off has been fast and furious, and the worst is most likely behind. We are underweight the Technology sector. Within the sector, we are underweight Semiconductors, and Hardware and Equipment. We are still overweight Software and Services for portfolio diversification purposes. The Software sector will be one of our next “deep dives.” Stay tuned. Are we there yet? No, we still have a few months to go. Structural Positioning While we reiterate our tactical underweighting of the Tech sector, we are bullish on it over the longer investment horizon. This sector is at the heart of US technological innovation, such as cloud computing, artificial intelligence, cybersecurity, chip design that powers EV and AV, and many others. The sector is home to some of the best American companies, which have powered US equities throughout the past decade, and will continue to do so for decades ahead. Bottom Line Despite a sell-off of NASDAQ and the Technology sector, we are not yet recommending increasing cyclical allocation to Tech: While technicals appear attractive, tighter monetary policy, the slowdown in demand for tech goods and services, pressures on profitability, and elevated valuations remain headwinds. We reiterate our underweight to the Technology sector on a tactical basis. We are structurally bullish. Irene Tunkel Chief Strategist, US Equity Strategy irene.tunkel@bcaresearch.com Recommended Allocation

